Starter Too Sour
StarterAn extremely sour or alcoholic-smelling starter has been underfed and the bacteria have dominated over yeast. The good news is this is easily fixed with more frequent feeding.
Overly sour starter occurs when acid-producing bacteria outpace yeast, usually from infrequent feeding or warm temperatures. This page lists 3 things to do now and the 4 most likely causes, each with the change to make next time.
What to do now
These apply to what is in front of you now. The deeper fixes and the changes for next time follow further down.
- Discard most of the starter, keeping only 1-2 tablespoons
- Feed with a larger ratio of fresh flour (1:5:5 or 1:10:10)
- Feed twice daily until smell improves
What usually causes it
Most likely first. The tell is what points to that cause rather than the others.
Feeding too infrequent
The tell: There is a sharp vinegar or alcohol smell, and the starter had already collapsed before you fed it.
Next time: Feed the starter before it collapses and becomes very sour.
Starter kept too warm
The tell: It peaks and sours quickly in a warm spot.
Next time: Store the starter in the refrigerator if you are not baking daily.
Used past its peak
The tell: The starter had already fallen when you used it.
Next time: Use the starter at peak, doubled and still domed, for a milder flavor.
Too little fresh flour per feeding
The tell: The starter stays acidic even when fed regularly.
Next time: Use more fresh flour per feeding to dilute the acidity.
Signs you’ve fixed it
- It smells tangy but not sharp — more like mild yogurt than vinegar. The vinegar smell is acetic acid from an exhausted culture.
- After a regular feed at room temperature, it peaks within 4–8 hours. An over-sour starter often peaks slowly or not at all.
Related problems
Questions
Is it safe to use a very sour starter?
Yes, it is safe but will produce very sour bread. The high acidity means the yeast may be sluggish, so bread may not rise as well.
What does hooch mean?
Hooch is the dark liquid that forms on neglected starter. It is alcohol produced by yeast. Pour it off or stir it in, then feed the starter.
How do I get less sour bread?
Use starter at peak before it becomes too acidic, ferment at cooler temperatures, and reduce fermentation time.