Skip to main content

Starter Not Rising

Starter

A starter that will not rise lacks the yeast and bacterial activity needed for bread baking. This can happen with new starters or neglected mature ones. With proper care, most starters can be revived.

Inactive starter results from insufficient yeast population, wrong temperature, irregular feeding, or contamination. This page lists 3 things to do now and the 4 most likely causes, each with the change to make next time.

What to do now

These apply to what is in front of you now. The deeper fixes and the changes for next time follow further down.

  • Feed with equal parts flour and water by weight and place in a warm spot
  • Ensure temperature is 75-80°F for optimal activity
  • Mark the level on the jar and check every few hours over the next 12-24 hours

What usually causes it

Most likely first. The tell is what points to that cause rather than the others.

  1. New starter not yet established

    The tell: The starter is only days old and shows a few bubbles at best.

    Next time: Keep feeding it consistently over 1-2 weeks to build a healthy yeast population.

  2. Starter kept too cold

    The tell: Activity picks up when the jar sits somewhere warmer.

    Next time: Keep the starter at 75-80°F for optimal activity.

  3. Irregular feeding

    The tell: Feeding times have wandered, and activity is patchy.

    Next time: Feed the starter at consistent times, because yeast thrives on routine.

  4. Chlorinated water

    The tell: Your tap water smells of chlorine, and activity improves with filtered water.

    Next time: Use filtered or bottled water if tap water is heavily chlorinated.

Signs you’ve fixed it

  • At peak, the starter has doubled in size and the surface looks domed — not flat.
  • Drop a teaspoon into water. If it floats, it's ready. Bubbles throughout, fresh tangy smell — not flat or alcoholic.
  • More reliable than the float test: the surface jiggles when you nudge the jar and you can see bubbles through the sides.

Related problems

Questions

How long does it take to start a new starter?

A new starter typically takes 7-14 days of consistent feeding to become reliably active. Be patient and keep feeding.

Can I revive an old neglected starter?

Usually yes. Discard all but a tablespoon, feed with fresh flour and water, and maintain consistent feeding. It may take several days.

What temperature is best for starter?

75-80°F is ideal. Cooler temperatures slow activity; warmer speeds it up but can make starter too sour.