Thick Crust
BakingWhile a good crust is prized in sourdough, an overly thick crust that is difficult to eat indicates overbaking, too much steam removal, or dough surface issues.
Thick crust develops from extended baking time, removing steam too early, or baking at too high temperature throughout. A baked loaf can't be re-baked into a different one, so this page lists the 4 most likely causes and the change to make for each on your next bake.
Can this loaf be saved?
The fixes are for your next bake (further down the page). What you can still do with this loaf:
- Keep it in a plastic bread bag for a few hours. Airtight wrapping softens the crust as moisture moves out from the crumb.
- Toast slices lightly, which makes a thick crust easier to bite.
What usually causes it
Most likely first. The tell is what points to that cause rather than the others.
Baked too long
The tell: The crust is deep brown, thick and hard to bite, and the thermometer was well past 205-210°F.
Next time: Use the internal temperature (205-210°F) as your guide and do not overbake.
Steam removed too early
The tell: You took the lid off early and the crust thickened.
Next time: Keep the lid on the Dutch oven for the full 20 minutes.
Oven temperature too high
The tell: The crust darkens early and thickens before the inside is done.
Next time: Lower the temperature for the uncovered baking phase.
Dough surface dried out before baking
The tell: The dough skinned over during the proof.
Next time: Ensure the dough surface is not dried out before baking.
Signs you’ve fixed it
- The crust is crisp and audibly crackly but doesn't take real force to cut through.
- Knock the bottom with a light tap — it sounds hollow. A thick-crusted loaf often needs a heavy knock before you hear anything.
Related problems
Questions
How thick should sourdough crust be?
Crust thickness is personal preference. Artisan sourdough typically has a substantial crust, but it should not be so thick it is hard to bite.
Does steam affect crust thickness?
Yes. Steam keeps the crust soft longer, allowing more rise. When steam is removed, crust sets. More steam time = thinner, crispier crust.
Why is my crust so hard?
Extended baking time dries out the crust. Try reducing bake time or temperature after removing the Dutch oven lid.