Skip to main content

No Ear

Baking

The "ear" is the flap of crust that peels back from a score mark during baking. It is prized for aesthetics and texture. Getting a good ear requires proper scoring, steam, and dough condition.

No ear forms when scoring angle is too steep, steam is insufficient, dough is overproofed, or the cut is too shallow. A baked loaf can't be re-baked into a different one, so this page lists the 5 most likely causes and the change to make for each on your next bake.

A round, deep-brown sourdough loaf on a cooling rack, dusted with flour, with a long cut that has opened and lifted along one edge and a short cut beside it.
What you are aiming for: the cut has opened and one edge has lifted into a raised lip of crust, the ear. Photo: one of our own bakes.

Can this loaf be saved?

The fixes are for your next bake (further down the page). What you can still do with this loaf:

  • Eat it: an ear changes how the loaf looks, not how it tastes.

What usually causes it

Most likely first. The tell is what points to that cause rather than the others.

  1. Scoring angle too steep

    The tell: The cut went straight down, near 90 degrees, and the edges opened without lifting.

    Next time: Score at a 30-45 degree angle from the dough surface.

  2. Dull blade dragging

    The tell: The edges of the cut are torn and ragged.

    Next time: Use a sharp lame or a fresh razor blade.

  3. Not enough steam

    The tell: The crust set early and the cut barely opened.

    Next time: Ensure adequate steam for the first 20 minutes of baking.

  4. Overproofed dough that cannot spring

    The tell: The dough was slack and deflated as you cut it.

    Next time: Shorten the final proof, or proof in the fridge and bake straight from it, so the dough still has spring.

  5. Score too shallow

    The tell: The cut barely opened and the loaf looks flat across the top.

    Next time: Cut deeper with one swift, confident stroke.

Signs you’ve fixed it

  • The score opened cleanly and pushed the flap of dough up and to one side.
  • A small ear is still an ear. Completely flat means the score was too shallow, or the dough was too warm going in.

Related problems

Questions

What angle should I score at for an ear?

Hold the blade at 30-45 degrees from the dough surface. This angle creates a flap that can lift during oven spring.

Does scoring depth affect the ear?

Yes. Too shallow and nothing happens. About 1/4 to 1/2 inch deep gives the ear room to form without weakening the loaf.

Why does my ear not lift?

Usually insufficient oven spring from overproofing, lack of steam, or scoring at too steep an angle. Cold dough and plenty of steam help.