Skip to main content

Poor Scoring

Baking

Scoring that does not open, drags, or looks ragged affects both appearance and oven spring. Proper blade angle, sharpness, and dough condition all play roles.

Poor scoring results from dull blades, wrong angle, hesitant cuts, over-proofed dough, or wet dough surface. A baked loaf can't be re-baked into a different one, so this page lists the 5 most likely causes and the change to make for each on your next bake.

Two oval sourdough loaves on a cooling rack: the left one with four diagonal cuts opened wide, the right one with cuts that barely opened.
Two loaves from one of our bakes. On the left the cuts opened wide; on the right they barely opened. Photo: one of our own bakes.

Can this loaf be saved?

The fixes are for your next bake (further down the page). What you can still do with this loaf:

  • Eat it: scoring changes how the loaf looks, not how it tastes.

What usually causes it

Most likely first. The tell is what points to that cause rather than the others.

  1. Dull blade

    The tell: The blade drags and tears the surface instead of slicing it.

    Next time: Use a fresh razor blade or a sharp lame.

  2. Hesitant, sawing motion

    The tell: The cut is jagged and made in several strokes.

    Next time: Move swiftly and confidently, because hesitation causes dragging.

  3. Blade angle too steep

    The tell: The cut goes straight down and the edges do not lift.

    Next time: Score at a 30-45 degree angle from the dough surface.

  4. Overproofed dough that deflates when cut

    The tell: The dough sinks as the blade goes in.

    Next time: Score cold dough straight from the refrigerator.

  5. Wet or sticky dough surface

    The tell: The blade catches and sticks on the dough.

    Next time: Flour or oil the blade if it sticks.

Signs you’ve fixed it

  • The blade feels like it's slicing silk — smooth, no drag. Dragging means the blade is dull, the dough is warm, or you're hesitating.
  • The scored line looks clean and precise right after cutting. Ragged or torn edges mean the blade pulled instead of cut.

Related problems

Questions

What blade is best for scoring?

A double-edge razor blade in a lame handle works best. Change blades frequently. They dull quickly on dough.

How deep should I score?

About 1/4 to 1/2 inch. Too shallow and it does not open; too deep and you deflate the dough.

Why does my blade drag?

The blade may be dull, the angle too steep, or the dough surface wet. Try a new blade, shallower angle, and dry surface.