Skip to main content

Float Test Fails

Mixing

Shows at: Mixing · Usually starts: with the starter

The float test (dropping a spoonful of starter in water to see if it floats) indicates gas production. If it sinks, the starter may not be active enough for baking.

Starter fails float test when it lacks sufficient gas bubbles to float, either from being past peak or not active enough. This page lists 3 things to do now and the 4 most likely causes, each with the change to make next time.

What to do now

These apply to what is in front of you now. The deeper fixes and the changes for next time follow further down.

  • If it is still rising, wait: it may not be at peak yet.
  • Feed starter and check again in 4-6 hours
  • Look for other signs: bubbles, volume increase, domed top

What usually causes it

Most likely first. The tell is what points to that cause rather than the others.

  1. Tested after the starter peaked and collapsed

    The tell: The starter has fallen and the surface is flat.

    Next time: Test at peak, when the starter has doubled and is still domed.

  2. Tested too soon after feeding

    The tell: Only a short time has passed since the feed, and there are few bubbles.

    Next time: Note the timing from feed to peak for your starter.

  3. Starter genuinely inactive

    The tell: There are no bubbles and no rise at all after feeding.

    Next time: Revive the starter first: see the guide to a starter that is not rising (/fix/starter-not-rising/).

  4. Float test unreliable for your starter

    The tell: The starter doubles and looks bubbly but still sinks.

    Next time: Use multiple indicators: doubling, bubbles, a domed top and a pleasant smell.

Signs you’ve fixed it

  • The teaspoon of starter bobs at the surface with part above the waterline — doesn't need to rocket to the top.
  • The float test is a decent quick check but it's not the whole story. A starter that looks domed, smells fresh-tangy, and has bubbles throughout is ready, float or not.

Related problems

Questions

Is the float test always accurate?

No. Some healthy starters sink due to hydration or flour type. Use it as one indicator among several. Volume increase and bubbles matter too.

When should I do the float test?

At peak activity, when starter has doubled and still has a domed top. Testing past peak (collapsed) will often fail.

Can I bake with starter that sinks?

If it shows other signs of activity (bubbles, rise), yes. The bread may rise more slowly. Very inactive starter will not leaven well.